(567 days)
The Belzer UW Cold Storage Solution preserves organs, by cold storage, just as well as currently marketed media, such as Collins' solution. Belzer UW Cold Storage Solution, hereafter known as BELZER UW-CSS, can be used for cold storage of the liver, pancreas, and kidney. BELZER UW-CSS has the potential to be used as a general solution for most organs, both for initial cooling during in situ donor organ flushing and for subsequent cold storage.
Not Found
Here's a breakdown of the acceptance criteria and the study that proves the device meets them, based on the provided text:
Device: BELZER UW Cold Storage Solution (BELZER UW-CSS)
Purpose: Preservation of organs (liver, pancreas, kidney) by cold storage for transplantation.
1. Table of Acceptance Criteria and Reported Device Performance
The acceptance criteria are implicitly defined by demonstrating equivalence or superiority to existing solutions (Collins' or EuroCollins' Solution - ECS) in terms of preservation time and post-transplant organ function.
| Organ | Acceptance Criteria (Implicit) | Reported BELZER UW-CSS Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Kidney | Equivalence/superiority to ECS in preserving kidneys for successful transplantation, including acceptable post-transplant renal function. | Superiority: All dogs survived after kidney storage for 48-72 hours in BELZER UW-CSS, compared to 0% survival after 72 hours in ECS and 80% survival after 48 hours in ECS. Initial post-transplant renal function (serum creatinine) was better with BELZER UW-CSS. |
| Liver | Equivalence/superiority to ECS in extending preservation time and demonstrating comparable or improved post-transplant liver function. | Superiority: Mean preservation time significantly longer (10.39 hours vs. 5.53 hours for ECS, p<0.01). Lower SGOT and SGPT on Day 1. Lower alkaline phosphatase at Day 7. Lower retransplantation rate (10 vs. 19 for ECS). Lower incidence of hepatic artery thrombosis (3 vs. 7 for ECS). |
| Pancreas | Equivalence to ECS in post-transplant pancreas function, with potential for extended preservation time. | Equivalence: Mean preservation time significantly longer (8.7 hours vs. 3.7 hours for ECS). No statistically significant differences in Day 1 serum amylase, urinary amylase, or blood glucose. Overall post-operative amylase levels not significantly different. |
2. Sample Sizes Used for the Test Set and Data Provenance
-
Kidney (Preclinical Data):
- Sample Size: Not explicitly stated, described as a "dog transplant model."
- Data Provenance: Preclinical animal study.
-
Liver (Clinical Data):
- Test Set (BELZER UW-CSS): 122 livers
- Control/Comparator Set (ECS): 126 livers
- Data Provenance:
- BELZER UW-CSS: Prospective clinical study, potentially multi-institutional (donor and recipient selection followed requirements established by "respective institutions").
- ECS: Retrospective clinical data.
-
Pancreas (Clinical Data):
- Test Set (BELZER UW-CSS): 9 grafts
- Control/Comparator Set (ECS): 6 grafts
- Data Provenance:
- BELZER UW-CSS: Prospective clinical study.
- ECS: Retrospective clinical data.
3. Number of Experts Used to Establish the Ground Truth for the Test Set and Qualifications of Those Experts
Not applicable based on the provided text. This study involves clinical outcomes and laboratory measurements, not expert review of images or diagnoses. The "ground truth" is derived from physiological measurements and clinical events (e.g., survival, retransplantation, laboratory values).
4. Adjudication Method for the Test Set
Not applicable based on the provided text. This involves objective clinical and laboratory measurements, not subjective evaluations requiring adjudication.
5. If a Multi-Reader Multi-Case (MRMC) Comparative Effectiveness Study Was Done
No, an MRMC study was not done. The study design is a comparison of organ preservation solutions based on clinical outcomes and laboratory markers.
6. If a Standalone (i.e., algorithm only without human-in-the-loop performance) Was Done
Not applicable. This is a medical device (a solution) used during a surgical procedure, not an AI algorithm.
7. The Type of Ground Truth Used
- Kidney: Dog survival rates, initial post-transplant renal function (serum creatinine values).
- Liver: Post-transplant graft function assessed by selected clinical laboratory variables (SGOT, SGPT, alkaline phosphatase, total bilirubin, prothrombin time and partial thromboplastin time), retransplantation rates, deaths, incidence of hepatic artery thrombosis.
- Pancreas: Post-transplant graft function assessed by serum and urinary amylase values, and blood glucose levels.
These are all outcomes data and laboratory data/physiological markers.
8. The Sample Size for the Training Set
Not applicable. This is a medical device (a solution), not a machine learning model that requires a training set.
9. How the Ground Truth for the Training Set Was Established
Not applicable, as there is no training set for this type of device.
{0}------------------------------------------------
APR 22 1996
SUMMARY OF SAFETY AND EFFICACY SUBMITTED IN 1988 TO SUPPORT ORIGINAL 510(k) FILING
Introduction
The Belzer UW Cold Storage Solution preserves organs, by cold storage, just as well as currently marketed media, such as Collins' solution. Belzer UW Cold Storage Solution, hereafter known as BELZER UW-CSS, can be used for cold storage of the liver, pancreas, and kidney. BELZER UW-CSS has the potential to be used as a general solution for most organs, both for initial cooling during in situ donor organ flushing and for subsequent cold storage. Use of BELZER UW-CSS could transform liver and pancreas transplantation from emergency operations to semi-elective procedures.
Preclinical Data
Kidney
Currently, kidneys are preserved by cold storage in Collins' or EuroCollins' solution (ECS) for cold storage transportation for clinical transplantation. Preservation in these solutions is limited to 48 hours. A comparison of EuroCollins' solution to BELZER UW-CSS in a dog transplant model gave 80% survival of dogs receiving kidneys stored for 48 hours in EuroCollins', but no dog survived after organ storage for 72 hours in this solution. In contrast, all dogs transplanted with kidneys preserved in BELZER UW-CSS for 48 to 72 hours survived. Initial post transplant renal function was better in kidneys stored in BELZER UW-CSS, as indicated by serum creatinine values immediately post-transplant and the rapid return of renal function to normal. Thus, storage in BELZER UW-CSS produces less damage to the kidney than storage in ECS. The results of this study indicate the equivalency, and suggest superiority of the BELZER UW-CSS to ECS for kidney preservation.
Clinical Data
Liver
A clinical study compared EuroCollins' Solution (ECS) and the BELZER UW-CSS as preservation and cold storage media for livers harvested for orthotopic transplant. Data for ECS were collected retrospectively, while BELZER UW-CSS data were gathered prospectively. The sample consisted of 126 livers preserved in ECS and 122 livers preserved in BELZER UW-CSS.
Once a donor became available, the liver was isolated and flushed in sity with lactated Ringer's solution and/or ECS solution. The final ex-vivo flush utilized either ECS or BELZER UW-CSS with subsequent storage in the same medium. The preservation time for each liver was recorded. After transplantation, graft function was assessed by the following selected clinical laboratory variables (SGOT, SGPT, alkaline phosphatase, total bilirubin, prothrombin time and partial thromboplastin time) for seven days after surgery and at one month post transplant. Post transplant patient follow up included monitoring for indication of graft dysfunction or rejection, which might indicate the need for a retransplantation. Donor and recipient selection followed the requirements established by the respective institutions sponsoring the transplant procedure.
Two hundred forty-eight liver transplants (126 in ECS group and 122 in the BELZER UW-CSS group) were done in 219 patients. Mean liver preservation times were significantly different for the two treatment groups, with BELZER UW-CSS livers preserved 88% longer than ECS livers (see Table 1).
{1}------------------------------------------------
| Table 1 | ||
|---|---|---|
| ECS(n=126) | BELZER UW-CSS(n=122) | |
| Mean Preservation Time (hours) | 5.53±0.14 | 10.39±0.47 (p<0.01) |
| Range (hours) | 0.75-10.0 | 0.5-28.7 |
The principle differences among the various laboratory values examined between the two treatment groups occurred in SGOT, SGPT, total bilirubin and alkaline phosphatase. Mean levels of SGOT and SGPT in BELZER UW-CSS patients were significantly lower than ECS patients on the first day after surgery.
The differences between the ECS and BELZER UW-CSS groups in total bilirubin and alkaline phosphatase became apparent in the seven-day follow-up period. At the end of seven days, alkaline phosphatase levels in the BELZER UW-CSS patients were significantly lower than those in the ECS patients whereas total bilirubin levels were slightly higher in BELZER UW-CSS patients, than in ECS patients.
The need for retransplantation was higher in the ECS group, compared to the BELZER UW-CSS group (19 vs. 10). There were 23 deaths over 21.5 months for ECS patients compared to seven deaths over four months in the BELZER UW-CSS group. The incidence of hepatic artery thrombosis was greater for ECS patients (7 vs. 3), as well. It should be noted, the observation period for patients in the retrospective (ECS) sample was longer than that for BELZER UW-CSS patients (21.5 vs. 4 months).
In conclusion, BELZER UW-CSS was found to compare favorably with the present preservation cold storage solution, ECS. These data show that the use of BELZER UW-CSS for liver preservation prior to transplant can safely extend storage times. In addition, livers preserved in BELZER UW-CSS solution showed better post transplant function, as evidenced by lower enzyme levels (SGOT, SGPT), when compared to livers preserved with ECS.
A safety concern with the use of both Collins' solution or BELZER UW-CSS relates to the high potassium concentration. Both of these solutions must be flushed from the vascular space of the preserved liver prior to transplantation to prevent a systemic overload of potassium. Therefore, no contraindications to use of this solution are anticipated particularly since this solution is not given to the patient but is flushed from the donor organ prior to transplantation.
Pancreas
A clinical study was performed to compare the effectiveness of ECS and the BELZER UW-CSS as preservation media for cold storage of human pancreas grafts intended for transplant.
ECS data (six grafts) were collected retrospectively while BELZER UW-CSS data (nine grafts) were obtained prospectively. Graft function post transplant was assessed by examining serum and urinary amylase values, as well as blood glucose levels, for seven days following surgery and at one month.
{2}------------------------------------------------
The mean preservation time for pancreas grafts stored in BELZER UW-CSS was significantly longer than for those stored in ECS (Table 2).
| Table 2 | ||
|---|---|---|
| ECSn=6 | BELZER UW-CSSn=9 | |
| Mean Preservation Time (hours) | $3.7\pm0.3$ | $8.7\pm1.4$ |
| Range (hours) | 3.0-5.0 | 4.0-16.0 |
There were no statistically significant differences in mean Day 1 serum amylase, urinary amylase or blood glucose levels between the two treatment groups, although Day 1 serum amylase values were higher in ECS versus BELZER UW-CŠS patients.
Over the seven day postoperative period, serum and urinary amylase levels were not significantly different in the ECS and BELZER UW-CSS groups. However, blood glucose values tended to increase at the end of the week in ECS patients, but decreased in BELZER UW-CSS patients.
In conclusion, these data show that pancreas grafts preserved with BELZER UW-CSS or EC are substantially equivalent when compared by post transplant function.
Summary
Results from clinical trials demonstrate the ability of this solution to safely preserve kidney, liver, and pancreas prior to transplantation. Furthermore, this solution extends the preservation time for all of these organs compared with the duration of organ preservation deemed safe and effective with Collins' solution. This should increase the supply of much needed and valuable donor organs by reducing organ wastage.
Thus, this solution is both safe and substantially equivalent to Collins' and EuroCollins solutions.
§ 876.5880 Isolated kidney perfusion and transport system and accessories.
(a)
Identification. An isolated kidney perfusion and transport system and accessories is a device that is used to support a donated or a cadaver kidney and to maintain the organ in a near-normal physiologic state until it is transplanted into a recipient patient. This generic type of device may include tubing, catheters, connectors, an ice storage or freezing container with or without bag or preservatives, pulsatile or nonpulsatile hypothermic isolated organ perfusion apparatus with or without oxygenator, and disposable perfusion set.(b)
Classification. Class II (performance standards).